32 replies to this topic

[simpleman]

I’m not saying they will be there, but these are the QBs and the rounds I’d be comfortable with the Bills drafting them in if they were available.  I’m assuming there are no trades up or down, so we are drafting at our assigned positions.  If we traded down with our 1^st  for a late first and an extra 1^st or 2^nd , I would be comfortable with taking one of the round 2 QBs with a late 1^st. What would be your Round / QB comfort list?

Round 1   Smith

Round 2   Wilson, Manuel

Round 3,4 Dysert, Scott, Brey, Nassib

Edited by simpleman, 19 March 2013 - 05:14 PM.

[swnybillsfan]

any quarterback, any round. i don't care who or where as long as they feel strongly about the guy. just pick a guy and don't appologize for it, if it doesn't work out try again next year.

[chris heff]

swnybillsfan, on 19 March 2013 - 05:51 PM, said:

any quarterback, any round. i don't care who or where as long as they feel strongly about the guy. just pick a guy and don't appologize for it, if it doesn't work out try again next year.

And keeping taking them until you get it right

[VanCity]

So, you are not okay with Barkley at all then?

I can't argue with your list, except I'll throw Barkley into my second round list
Round 1   Smith

Round 2   Barkley, Wilson, Manuel

Round 3,4 Dysert, Scott, Brey, Nassib

UDFA-Jones (just for a look-see)

[stony]

I'll take Barkley in Rd. 1. Gotta take a chance on a QB sooner or later. Funny how a great year followed by a good year knocked this guy down in so many people's minds.

[kickedface]

sounds good to me

[Section242]

1. Barkley, Smith
2. Wilson, Bray

If they wait til the 3rd rd i'd fire Nix immediately.

[simpleman]

VanCity, on 19 March 2013 - 06:02 PM, said:

So, you are not okay with Barkley at all then?

I can't argue with your list, except I'll throw Barkley into my second round list

No, I would be absolutely fine with Barkley along with the round 2 choices, I just don't see any remote possibility of him lasting that long.

[Cru Jones]

1. Barkley, but not at #8.
2. Smith, Wilson.
3. Glennon.

If they don't have a guy in the first 3 rounds I don't care what round they get someone.
in order of preference from rd 3 on.

Jones
Nassib
Manuel
Bray

After these guys there's nobody that I believe is worth drafting at this point in their development.

[chris heff]

simpleman, on 19 March 2013 - 05:13 PM, said:

I’m not saying they will be there, but these are the QBs and the rounds I’d be comfortable with the Bills drafting them in if they were available.  I’m assuming there are no trades up or down, so we are drafting at our assigned positions.  If we traded down with our 1^st  for a late first and an extra 1^st or 2^nd , I would be comfortable with taking one of the round 2 QBs with a late 1^st. What would be your Round / QB comfort list?

Round 1   Smith

Round 2   Wilson, Manuel

Round 3,4    Dysert, Scott, Brey, Nassib

Take them all and let God sort them out.

[Aus Bills]

Geno Smith isnt getting past jags,raiders,browns and cards. I doubt Barkley will be available at 8 either. EJ Manuel in the 2nd is the likely option.

[Johnny Hammersticks]

Aus Bills, on 19 March 2013 - 09:37 PM, said:

Geno Smith isnt getting past jags,raiders,browns and cards. I doubt Barkley will be available at 8 either. EJ Manuel in the 2nd is the likely option.

Manuel won't be there at #41 IMO.  In fact, I'm willing to be my third nut that he goes in the top 20.

[J-Gun Boone]

Round 1- Barkley, Manuel, Geno

Round 2- too late

[Meathead]

take six qbs this draft and keep the best two

[Dadonkadonk]

stony, on 19 March 2013 - 06:39 PM, said:

I'll take Barkley in Rd. 1. Gotta take a chance on a QB sooner or later. Funny how a great year followed by a good year knocked this guy down in so many people's minds.

Actuaaly it was more like a very good year followed by a very average to bad year filled with questionable decisions and a rag arm....no thank you...he can take his team jesus act 2.0 somewhere else

[the skycap]

simpleman, on 19 March 2013 - 05:13 PM, said:

I’m not saying they will be there, but these are the QBs and the rounds I’d be comfortable with the Bills drafting them in if they were available.  I’m assuming there are no trades up or down, so we are drafting at our assigned positions.  If we traded down with our 1^st  for a late first and an extra 1^st or 2^nd , I would be comfortable with taking one of the round 2 QBs with a late 1^st. What would be your Round / QB comfort list?

Round 1   Smith

Round 2   Wilson, Manuel

Round 3,4    Dysert, Scott, Brey, Nassib

Not high on Glennon, huh?

[MDFan]

swnybillsfan, on 19 March 2013 - 05:51 PM, said:

any quarterback, any round. i don't care who or where as long as they feel strongly about the guy. just pick a guy and don't appologize for it, if it doesn't work out try again next year.

This.

[Kellyto83TD]

swnybillsfan, on 19 March 2013 - 05:51 PM, said:

any quarterback, any round. i don't care who or where as long as they feel strongly about the guy. just pick a guy and don't appologize for it, if it doesn't work out try again next year.

^^

This.

I love how guys say 'well this guy isn't worth taking till this round'. Really?  if we could go back right now would these same fans be willing to spend our first round pick on Wilson or Capernick?  So lets cut the draft who in what round crap and draft a damn QB already

[auburnbillsbacker]

swnybillsfan, on 19 March 2013 - 05:51 PM, said:

any quarterback, any round. i don't care who or where as long as they feel strongly about the guy. just pick a guy and don't appologize for it, if it doesn't work out try again next year.

Since there might not be a blue chip prospect in this draft the bills need to be prepared to draft another QB next year as well.  If both QBs develop into stars you can trade one.  If only one turns into a star, it was a good thing you drafted two.  If both suck, it doesn't matter because without a good QB the bills would not have competed for a championship anyways.

[Kellyto83TD]

auburnbillsbacker, on 20 March 2013 - 10:44 AM, said:

Since there might not be a blue chip prospect in this draft the bills need to be prepared to draft another QB next year as well.  If both QBs develop into stars you can trade one.  If only one turns into a star, it was a good thing you drafted two.  If both suck, it doesn't matter because without a good QB the bills would not have competed for a championship anyways.

Capernick wasn't a blue chip. Wilson wasn't a blue chip according to the same 'Experts' on ESPN, NFLN etc and they were wrong. Just like they will be wrong on 2-3 of these guys.